Stop Giving To Charity

Now that I have your attention, I should really finish this sentence…

Stop giving to charity as an individual follower of Jesus.

What I’m suggesting may seem a bit radical to some, but in the context of history, what I’m proposing is actually quite ordinary.

I’ve written this post in my mind a hundred times, and I’ve harboured this conviction for many years, but it wasn’t until I engaged in 2011 budget planning for my new congregation that this conviction was lured to the surface.

What is true of St. Andrew’s Kirk has been true of every congregation I’ve ever been formally connected to. Only a very small percentage of our revenue is dispersed for benevolent purposes. The message this sends to the world is this: We care only about ourselves.

That’s the message conveyed by the bare numbers of a church budget, but it is not an accurate message. My experience, in every congregation that I’ve served, is that individual Christians are very generous toward benevolent organizations. The trouble is, as a group (as a church) we are not conveying this generous spirit to our local community because we’re not giving as a group—we’re giving as individuals.

When Bryn MacPhail makes a donation to the Cancer Society, the effect is that Bryn MacPhail gets the credit. The Cancer Society doesn’t know Bryn MacPhail is a Christian, nor do they know anything about what motivates Bryn’s generosity.

Now imagine there are 100 Christians in a local congregation giving, as individuals, an average of $200 each to the same charity. Again, if it’s a big organization there is no way for the charity to know what is behind the motivation of the giver. What if, instead, we all made the same dollar donation, but coordinated that donation through the local church. Then you have a local Christian congregation giving $20,000 to a local charity.

What is the effect of the local church giving $20,000 instead of 100 individuals each giving $200? The effect is that the local church gets the credit rather than the individual. And whom does the local church represent? The Lord Jesus Christ.

Ultimately then, God is most glorified in our giving when we give together in a coordinated manner.

Now, replicate this experience by, say, ten charities. The Cancer Society. The local hospital. The neighbourhood school. The Women’s shelter. The orphanage. The inner city community center. The relief efforts in Haiti. Support for missionaries in Nicaragua. The local food bank. A local scholarship fund. Just examples. Each getting $10,000-30,000 donations by a group of people who profess to be following the way of their Master, Jesus Christ.

It is my sincere conviction that we diminish our witness when we fly solo, but we strengthen our witness when we coordinate and work together.

If this sounds too radical, we need to remember that this was normal protocol for Christians and their congregations less than a Century ago. It was once a normal thing for a congregation to build a hospital. It was once an expected thing for a congregation to found a school. There was a time when governments depended upon the Church to care for the poor and the most vulnerable. And we were good at it! No other non-government organization on earth has built more schools, hospitals, shelters, or orphanages than the Church.

We’re building less and less these days. I think it is because we have split up. We’re each doing our own thing.

The community around us looks to the Church and wants to know what contribution we are willing to make. We can do so much more if we do it together.

This past week I had the privilege of delivering food packages (supplied by the people of the Kirk) to impoverished homes in Bain & Grant’s Town, in downtown Nassau. I was accompanied and directed by staff from the local Urban Renewal Center. Neighbourhood children got word of our food supply and literally chased down our vehicle until we stopped and handed each of them some fresh fruit.

The reality is that the food we delivered that day came from a collection of people, and not one person. The food came from a collection of people who were motivated by a love for Jesus and by a genuine concern for the people of the neighbourhood.

The word is getting out. The people of the Kirk care. We care a lot.

I am convinced that the best way to further that perception is by serving together. Accordingly, may I boldly suggest that we arrest this practice of giving to charity as individual Christians. Instead, let’s take the time to coordinate our efforts, and to combine our generosity, with a view to maximizing our capacity to glorify Jesus Christ.

6 thoughts on “Stop Giving To Charity

  1. Powerful Message. Lessons Learned.

    Thank you Bryn for being provoked to be “Being Led By The Spirit”.

    Thank you for helping us understand that our giving is to Glorify Him.

  2. Thank you Bryn for your “radical” comments. It is a policy that whole hearted support. In the past we could not see the forest for the trees and
    failed to emulate Christ’s teachings. St. Andrew’s is fortunate to have your leadership and cannot help but make a difference in the community.

  3. Bryan,
    I have been talking about this to a number of people around the church. It certainly generating some interesting discussion. I wonder if it will lead to more action. Time will tell.
    Keep trail blazing! Blessings Jim

  4. Hi Jim,
    You’ve nailed the next key issue on this—application. Once a group of church leaders agree on this principle, the next step is making it a reality in practice.
    God bless!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *